I didn’t think it was possible.
But there it is. Variety gave Super Mario Galaxy a bad review.
I always hate these comments about the best next-gen graphics. I have seen some games that have amazing graphics on other systems. And sure, it is impressive. But a lot of them are really boring. For example, take any squad based shooter. People don’t play those for the graphics. They play them for the multiplayer experience. This is part of gameplay. The fact that they look good is unrelated to their success. The same applies to Mario. Mario is always fun. It always has been. Always will be. I do not want to see perfectly rendered denim overalls drenched in Italian plumber sweat in 1080p. That isn’t the goddamn point. The point is the gameplay. The point is the experience. No one cares that Guitar Hero’s guitarists aren’t realistic, because the gameplay is amazing.
I really wish reviewers would focus mostly on the gameplay, and less on how the entire experience looks on your HDTV. If you are playing games because you want them to have realistic effects…why don’t you just look around real life and enjoy yourself? If you want to play them for the gameplay, then remember that graphics are a relatively unimportant side-story.
I want to do a larger post on the flawwed review system for games, but we’ll get back to that later. I have a midterm today.