[UPDATE: I edited the post so that I was not painting all the writers at Gamestooge with the same brush. All of my comments are directed towards the writer of the piece, jonahfalcon.]
Can you believe this?
To me, that sounds ridiculous. Perhaps Binkle can weigh in on this with a bit more legal input than us peons, but it is the most ludicrous accusation I have ever heard. The points that he provides are meaningless fluff pulled out of the air. Those situations are not analogous to progressing through a game.
I can only imagine what [jonahfalcon does whenever he is] watching a TV show, reading a book or enjoying a movie.
“What do you mean I have to watch the 21 episodes before they air the fuckin’ season finale? This is bullshit man. What you’re doing is criminal!”
“I can’t believe you want me to read this entire book. I just want to know how it fuckin’ ends. What a rip off!”
“Why can’t they just get to the climax of this damn movie? FUCK!”
But, then again, maybe they have a point. Think of dating fellas. We work up the courage to ask a girl out. We go out on a few dates. We buy her drinks, her meals, her movie tickets, her cab ride home. And what happens if the relationship goes nowhere? What happens if she doesn’t put out?
This is illegal. I was under the impression that - in some sort of relationship setting - there is sex. I put forth the effort and the coin. So why can’t I just have sex with the woman? I’d say it is a done deal. And the logic of [jonahfalcon] completely validates my claim. Women are constantly engaging in criminal behaviour. Buy a woman dinner. Sleep with her. Such is the law of the universe now.
You buy games to complete them. And it isn’t that the songs are ‘unavailable’. You can get them easily by beating medium, which is not a challenge if you have ten fingers and have played a video game.
[As for jonahfalcon], it sounds like someone bought a game that he sucks balls at and he is disappointed. Well, it is not the fault of Harmonix, Red Octane, or Activision that you are some sort of autistic pile of flesh simmering unpleasantly in your own sweaty juices, desperately trying to grasp your axe and shred.
You have to admit, the notion is kind of funny.
In case Binkle (or anyone else) has a legal reason why this would actually make sense. In which case, we might have a debate on our hands. Unless that legal reason is completely irrefutable, in which case…shit.
EDIT: I commented under his editorial. It has yet to appear, so I will quote it here:
First of all, if there is indeed someone who purchases Guitar Hero II for a single song, then they are being absolutely foolish. Who would pay $100 to hear (and play) a mediocre cover of one song that they enjoy? If they are willing to throw money around like that, then they are the victims of foolish spending in general, and not some illegal action on the part of Harmonix or Red Octane.
As for your opinion jonahfalcon, perhaps the most appropriate analogy is this.
Mr. Smith, deciding that watching television was no longer for him given its strict limitations, walks into his local music shop to purchase an acoustic guitar. He also signs up for lessons.
Mr. Smith shows up for lessons and is told by his instructor that they are going to begin with theory, instead of actually playing the guitar. It is - after all - important to understand the fundamentals before you dive right in.
“This is ludicrous,” says Mr. Smith, “My favourite song is Purple Haze by Jimi Hendrix. I want to start off playing that.”
“I’m sorry Mr. Smith. With your experience, I doubt you would be able to handle that kind of song,” says the instructor.
“Well, damn. This is so illegal. I bought this guitar and signed up for these lessons under the impression that I would be able to play Jimi Hendrix, and now you’re telling me that I can’t? I will see you in court.”
Now there is a good analogy. The reason you have to “unlock” songs in medium in Guitar Hero II is because the game is teaching you how to play. Free Bird by Lynyrd Skynyrd is extremely difficult compared to Surrender by Cheap Trick. It is a learning curve. And after playing through medium, you are easily able to unlock all of the songs.
_It is hardly illegal. It is logical. Welcome to real life. _